Overtime Elation

Photo credit: Julia Wall
Photo credit: Julia Wall


WATERTOWN, Wis. -- After pummeling the resilient Emmaus Bible College Eagles for 102 minutes, the Sabercats finally broke through for a dramatic win.

Tyler Nelson scored a close-range winner in sudden death that gave the Sabercats an NCCAA regional victory in what is always a riveting battle with Emmaus.


  • Result: Maranatha 2-1 Emmaus (OT)
  • Venue: Maranatha Baptist University
  • Location: Watertown, Wis.
  • Attendance: 120
  • Records: MBU (1-2-0), EBC (0-5-0)


From start to finish, the Sabercats' relentless pressure was matched only with determined defending from the Eagles. In the opening 45 minutes, Maranatha amassed 21 shots and 15 corner kicks had no goals to show for it.

After a frustrating first half, the Sabercats finally broke through after seven minutes of second-half action. Nathan Campbell's free kick yielded a rebound from Jacob Bauer in the Emmaus goal, and Joel Shepard was on hand to tap in the rebound for his first collegiate goal.

But in just a matter of seconds, Emmaus equalized in spectacular fashion.

Straight from the kickoff, Carson McBain collected a pass and launched a shot from 60 yards away that flew right under the crossbar for an incredible and instant equalizer. McBain's effort left the Sabercats completely flummoxed for the time being.

Despite the unexpected setback, the Sabercats redoubled their scoring efforts but could not find a way past Bauer and the rest of the Eagles' defense. The whistle for 90 minutes blew and sudden-death overtime was next.

In the opening 10 minutes of overtime, a Maranatha win seemed inevitable but it never came. The Eagles cleared three shots off their own goal line, and the Sabercats started to think that this just wasn't their day.

But just two minutes into the second overtime period, the Sabercats finally got what they came for. Zeke Steuerwald forced Bauer to make a diving save, and after Josh Hockema's shot was blocked by an Emmaus defender, Nelson made no mistake in finishing the third shot in quick succession. Nelson's calm finish was the exclamation mark on yet another thrilling Maranatha-Emmaus clash, and it caused the Blue and Gold to finally breathe a sigh of relief.

MBU Starters: 1- Kinzler, 4- Roer, 5- Sturgill, 7- Nelson, 8- Campbell, 10- St. Lawrence (C), 11- DeAngelo (C), 12- Steuerwald, 15- J. Hockema, 18- Shepard, 19- C. Hockema (C)


  • Shot count: Maranatha 41-5 Emmaus
  • Steuerwald, Campbell, Bryant Sturgill: 4 shots on goal each
  • Asa St. LawrenceAustin DeAngeloCaleb HockemaShepard: all played 102 minutes for MBU
  • Tim Kinzler: 2 saves in the win
  • MBU: 20 corner kicks in the game
  • Last year: Maranatha beat the Eagles 4-3 in Iowa
  • Series: Maranatha now leads the series, 5-0-0


  • The Eagles join the Sabercats in the NCCAA North Region
  • Emmaus is off to an 0-5 start but have had multiple close losses
  • EBC has 10 regular-season games against NCCAA competition


The Sabercats will continue their home stand with a 1:30 clash with Lawrence University on Saturday. Watch live at mbusabercats.com/schedule.

Steps Forward
December 13, 2019 Steps Forward
Best of the Best
November 27, 2019 Best of the Best
Ending Together
November 21, 2019 Ending Together
Out of the Fire
November 20, 2019 Out of the Fire
Nationals Scouting Report
November 19, 2019 Nationals Scouting Report
St. Lawrence Honored
November 18, 2019 St. Lawrence Honored
The Best in the North
November 9, 2019 The Best in the North
Living to Fight
November 9, 2019 Living to Fight
Two of the Best
November 9, 2019 Two of the Best
Cold Snap
November 8, 2019 Cold Snap
Sizing up the Semis
November 7, 2019 Sizing up the Semis
Wide Open
October 29, 2019 Wide Open
Nelson Gets the Nod
October 28, 2019 Nelson Gets the Nod
No Stone Unturned
October 26, 2019 No Stone Unturned
Comeback Central
October 25, 2019 Comeback Central
Parents' Day Dominance
October 19, 2019 Parents' Day Dominance
Two Down
October 14, 2019 Two Down
V-Hawks Revisited
October 8, 2019 V-Hawks Revisited
Seven from Six
October 5, 2019 Seven from Six
Close-Knit Catfight
October 4, 2019 Close-Knit Catfight
Kinzler Collects
September 30, 2019 Kinzler Collects
Going to Work Early
September 28, 2019 Going to Work Early
Moody Mayhem
September 24, 2019 Moody Mayhem
Shepard Snags Award
September 23, 2019 Shepard Snags Award
Odds are Even
September 21, 2019 Odds are Even
Two For the Show
September 19, 2019 Two For the Show
NCCAA Top 10 - September 17
September 18, 2019 NCCAA Top 10 - September 17
Regional Rampage
September 17, 2019 Regional Rampage
September 14, 2019 Counter-Attacked
Overtime Elation
September 12, 2019 Overtime Elation
Sucker-Punch Shutout
September 9, 2019 Sucker-Punch Shutout
Bucked by the Bucs
September 6, 2019 Bucked by the Bucs
Maranatha Memories
August 31, 2019 Maranatha Memories
Eyes on the Prize
August 28, 2019 Eyes on the Prize
Regional Hosts Announced
June 13, 2019 Regional Hosts Announced