What Might Have Been

Photo credit: Ben Yenger
Photo credit: Ben Yenger


WATERTOWN, Wis. -- Down 12 points with less than two minutes left, Maranatha tied the game but left with a 75-73 defeat to Cardinal Stritch University in the final home game of the season.

Taylor Ball put up 26 points and Stephen Wilkerson marked his return to play with a double-double, but even the electric energy created in the Maranatha gym couldn't make the comeback happen.


  • Result: Maranatha 73-75 Stritch
  • Venue: Maranatha Baptist University
  • Location: Watertown, Wis.
  • Attendance: 222
  • Records: MBU (7-6), CSU (1-14)


Stritch was the better team in the first half, shooting 50 percent or better from the floor and downtown. Ball put up 19 points on his own but 11 Maranatha turnovers helped give Stritch a 48-33 halftime lead.

Maranatha sharpened up their possession but still had shooting trouble in the second half. Stritch stayed ahead by 10-12 into the final two minutes, but the same resolve that fueled the Maranatha comeback against Lincoln Christian came back into full view.

Caleb Moultrie jumper with :34 on the clock made it a six-point game, and Moultrie turned right around for a steal and an assist on the ensuing inbounds pass. A three from Wilkerson made it a one-point game with :29 left, and when Aaron Sanders stepped up to the line to tie the game, the walls of the Maranatha gym were shaking with the energy from the fans.

It was happening again.

But lightning didn't strike twice. Stritch's Orri Hilmarsson connected a jumper at the other end of the court, and Moultrie's winning shot at the horn clattered off the back iron. Despite the loss, the team once again showed that they had fight, resilience, and an unquestioned will to win.


Seniors Taylor Ball, Brenden Caldwell, Zeke Steuerwaldand Stephen Wilkerson all played their final home game for Maranatha.


Maranatha Starters: 2- T. Ball, 3- Mayhak, 4- Steuerwald, 5- Sanders, 23- Wilkerson // Stritch Starters: 10- Winters, 23- Popovic, 30- Hilmarsson, 33- Glisic, 34- Dillon


  • Ball: 26 PTS, 7 REB, 2 AST, 2 STL
  • Wilkerson: 17 PTS, 11 REB, 2 AST
  • Wilkerson: First game since January 18 
  • Moultrie: 9 PTS, 1 REB, 2 STL
  • MBU: 12 points behind with 2:00 left in the game
  • Last time: The Sabercats won 64-62 earlier this season
  • Series: Stritch now leads the series 36-19


  • Stritch competes in the Chicagoland College Athletic Conference of the NAIA DI
  • Stritch won the NAIA DII National Championship in 2013
  • Stritch finished last year with an 11-19 record


The Sabercats will travel to Palos Heights, Illinois Friday for a 5:00 p.m. tip at Trinity Christian. Find details at mbusabercats.com/schedule.

End of the Road
February 25, 2021 End of the Road
NCCAA Regionals Insider
February 24, 2021 NCCAA Regionals Insider
Hot Shot Havoc
February 19, 2021 Hot Shot Havoc
Four-Seed Framework
February 17, 2021 Four-Seed Framework
What Might Have Been
February 13, 2021 What Might Have Been
Comeback City
February 9, 2021 Comeback City
Twice Over
February 8, 2021 Twice Over
Ballin' in January
February 4, 2021 Ballin' in January
Just Short
January 30, 2021 Just Short
North Region Runaway
January 29, 2021 North Region Runaway
Basketball Games Postponed
January 26, 2021 Basketball Games Postponed
On the Back Foot
January 19, 2021 On the Back Foot
Put to the Sword
January 18, 2021 Put to the Sword
Evening the Odds
January 16, 2021 Evening the Odds
No Way Back
January 14, 2021 No Way Back
Weekly for Wilkerson
December 14, 2020 Weekly for Wilkerson
Setting it Straight
December 12, 2020 Setting it Straight
Fighting Through
December 11, 2020 Fighting Through
Revenge on Hold
December 4, 2020 Revenge on Hold
Basketball Games Cancelled
December 1, 2020 Basketball Games Cancelled
Thursday Game Postponed
November 18, 2020 Thursday Game Postponed
Weekend Games Postponed
November 11, 2020 Weekend Games Postponed
Back in Business
November 10, 2020 Back in Business
Back Together
November 9, 2020 Back Together
Season-Opener Cancelled
November 5, 2020 Season-Opener Cancelled
Eligibility Extended
October 29, 2020 Eligibility Extended